The week gone by saw Karat and his CPI-Mafioso make idiots of themselves with their bungling of events in Bengal from Nandigram to Taslima Nasreen. But the week also saw?Karat’s network of Useful Idiots make themselves heard, albeit with dangerous consequences.
The week began with Useful Idiots in High Places scripting a parallel foreign policy on the one hand while manufacturing fiction on the other.
First it was Vice President Hamid Ansari returning Don Karat’s favor with this speech at a conference on ?Emerging Security Concerns in West Asia? with these words
“The US has been mauled by non-state actors in Iraq; its policies have given an impetus to terrorism; it has lost domestic support for its Iraq policy; its unpopularity levels are alarmingly high in Arab and Muslim countries and its intentions are suspected,”
Who is he speaking for ?
Has he forgotten that his days of freewheeling op-eds in the Communist rag-tag Hindu are over and he is now holding a Constitutional Office ?
Perhaps Ansari was merely taking a cue from his Communist bosses on disregarding the UPA’s official foreign policy line rendering the Union Cabinet irrelevant. Some have dismissed the Vice President’s remarks as innocuous but there is a danger in viewing his remarks in isolation. After all Don Karat has his Useful Idiots across the globe who have in an unguarded?moment of crisis let the cat out of the bag.
In a public falling out the loony Pseudo Intellectual Left has expressed dismay of the loony International Left over what it calls a public relations coup by the CPI-M. So you have this rather amusing spectacle of Mahashweta Devi, Arundhati Roy, Sumit Sarkar, Uma Chakravarty, Tanika Sarkar, and others issuing a public letter to International Useful Idiots Noam Chomsky, Howard Zinn in protest.
Of what you ask ?
Noam Chomsky’s appeal to the loony Pseudo Intellectual Left to not split the Left in the face of American Imperialism
So there you have this Quixotic Alliance of Useful Idiots from India to the Americas ganging up to fight the Windmills of American Imperialism with Hamid Ansari playing Sancho Panza.
The perils of having a useful idiot for a Vice President !
This delusional enchantment with fighting “American Imperialism” is now infectious, breaching the Vindhyas. The dumbing down of Chandrababu Naidu from CEO of Andhra Pradesh to Prakash Karat’s Useful Idiot should go down in history as the most debilitating near death experience to one’s intellect. Naidu’s ideological somersaults have him defending the CPI-Mafioso over Nandigram and Taslima Nasreen in the same breath while hoping to win the Muslim vote in Andhra. With delusions of playing a role in national politics, Naidu’s new avatar as the bitter Middle Aged Man of Andhra Politics has him spending more time exchanging verbal abuses with Y.S. Rajashekhar Reddy in chaste Telugu than in contributing anything meaningful to the national discourse.
How dangerous can Naidu get by association with Prakash Karat ?
Well consider this. They called gutless wonder Shivraj Patil incompetent and not secular enough but that did not stop him from unwittingly joining their club of Useful Idiots to lend credence to the the CPI-M’s Maoist lie in Nandigram during last week’s debate in Parliament. Meanwhile the nation continues to pay for Shivraj Patil’s lack of intelligence?with last week’s serial blasts in Uttar Pradesh targeting courthouses and lawyers in Lucknow, Faizabad and Varnasi.
Well that’s how dangerous a useful idiot can get, and they dont even like him.
Now imagine what could happen if Chapter 2 in Project Karat gets anywhere close to reality come next elections ?
Offstumped Bottomline: With useful idiots in high places, Karat’s Quixotic Global Alliance is fraught with dangerous consequences to the Indian National Interest.
Filed under: Uncategorized
Yossarin.
In Assam of Congress ruled recently there was Image of Women Stripped Naked and beaten in the Strret.
I do compliment our Main stream Media in NOT making this incident as this just disturb the harmony and the culprit must be punished.
But Just wondering if that incident happened in Gujarat,Chattishgarh or Rajasthan of BJP ruled state.
Has it not been Splased in NDTV,CNN,HINDUSTAN TIMES and Comments from Shabana Azmi,Teesta,Arundhati,Brinda etc 5 Star Women Activist.
Prashant – fully agree there is a double standard in the way incidents are played up depending on which states they occur.
Hey, I have been reading and viewing reports on the incident on every TV channel and newspaper.
Good work Yossarin
I have recently discovered offstumped as I was looking for an alternate source of views other than our sick-ular, proto marxist and crypto arabic english media.
I think with this you have hit the nerve centre of Commie conspiracy, these guys pack all the opinion making places and leave little else to those who disagree with them.
Massada shall not fall again!!
Greetings
[...] post by yossarin Share These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web [...]
I think this post (except in criticizing Ansari) is a totally misguided one. India is far better off with commies fighting Imperialism than indulging in Muslim appeasement. In CPM, there are now two schools. The Karat way, whose target is Imperialism versus the Bengal way whose cause is political opportunism. We need to support the first.
Karat may use Muslim sentiments and muslim-vote seeking parties like SP or TDP. But his intentions are still noble. We do need parties that oppose American Imperialism. Afterall people need platforms to vent their fury. As Nitin asks elsewhere, one of the reasons for the current ‘mess’ is that media (including offstumped) forces established viewpoints on minority opinions.
When even Abdul Kalam advocates two-party or polar politics, we know this country is going to the dogs. A wonderful mix of liberal-socialist Congress, hindu-capitalist BJP, really-communist CPM, regional parties espousing state causes and fringe smaller parties espousing even separatist causes is the only way to maintain some sanity in this country. Votes or stones, you choose!
“Really-Communist CPM”
Balaji u r right.
And of this CPIM….THEY OWN NEWSPAPER,TV CHANNEL,AMUSEMENT PARK ETC in Kerala???????
So dear r they real Communist or Capitalist mearing the MASK of Communist
YOU DECIDE ON YOUR DEAR.
Balaji – those who look to foreigners to settle domestic political disputes are anti-national, period. There is no room for equivocation. Ganging up with a chomsky on the pretext of an “imaginary” bogey of “imperialism” has nothing to do with the indian national interest even for argument’s sake one assumes that “bogey” was real.
Firebrand – thanks keep visiting
http://www.hinduholocaust.com/HinduHolocaustMuseum.htm
The Hindu Holocaust continues throughout the world today. More than any other religious group anywhere, Hindus and being persecuted and murdered by fanatical members of other religious groups, and even by the Government of India itself. In the supposedly “secular” country of India, we find that the minority religions are given special treatment and allowed to manage their own affairs. Muslims in India are offered a financial subsidy to pay for their religious pilgrimage to Mecca (the Hajj Subsidy), and Christian missionaries are allowed to run rampant using various forms of deception and material promises to convert entire villages, while the Hindu religion is denigrated in India’s universities. Patriotic Hindus are called fundamentalists and fanatics, while Muslim and Christian terrorists carry out an unprecedented campaign of murder and violence against Hindus. Hindu temples are not allowed to be managed by the Hindus themselves, rather huge amounts of donations are collected by the “secular” government and pocketed by non-Hindu officials while the Temples are left to fall into ruins. At the same time, Muslim “Madrassas”, or religious schools, are growing by leaps and bounds, and left free to preach their hatred against Hindus. Muslim and Christian separatists threaten to tear Mother India apart even more than she has already been in order to secede and carve out new nations from India based on religious governments, rather than on secular lines that insure religious freedom for all.
Sonia rule
http://truecongresspolitics.wordpress.com/2007/11/27/are-we-heading-towards-a-christian-india/
truth about godhra and gujarat
http://truecongresspolitics.wordpress.com/2007/11/26/facts-speak-for-themselves/
Balaji – also what the hell does american imperialism have to do with states interests. From when linguistic regionalism come to mean dabbling in international geo-politics ?
yossarin- I agree with you 100%.No foreigners in matters of national importance. These idiots bring in Kissinger out of some shithole he has been hiding since realizing that China owns the Us now and to think he was the angel who started the dialouge. They need his pathetic help to convince us that we should hold BIG BROTHER’s hand. We truly need genius like you to highlight the Foriengn Hand. Hurrah! We are Saved !
Balaji- I salute you. A sane voice at last.
prashant- The tv, news paper , not by any one individual but a large body of people. when that happens it is called communism.
com·mu·nism \’käm-y?-”ni-z?m, -yü-\ n [F communisme, fr. commun common] (1840)
1 a : a theory advocating elimination of private property b : a system in which goods are owned in common and are available to all as needed
Sree please stop commenting on sanity of anyone either for or against, usage of personal slurs by questioning a person’s sanity is no way or rather in terms of commie way is the only way of conducting a dialogue.
Yours sanefully…..
prashant- The tv, news paper , not by any one individual but a large body of people. when that happens it is called communism.
com·mu·nism [F communisme, fr. commun common] (1840)
1 a : a theory advocating elimination of private property b : a system in which goods are owned in common and are available to all as needed
Sree – man are you dumb or what ? Get your facts right before one can take you seriously. Kissinger’s representing american interests is no different from any indian politician meeting american law makers in the USA to represent indian interests. Unless you have evidence that some political group in india hired kissinger to influence domestic political opinion your argument is fiction at its best. In any case offstumped held no brief for kissinger so funny you should bring it up here.try 10janpath7racecourz
http://www.hindu.com/2007/11/27/stories/2007112756181600.htm
Why is India negotiating a trade deal with a malaysia (in january 08), a country that actively persecuting hindus ! Pressure must be brought on Congress Govt to instruct Malaysian Govt to rebuild the thousands of temples destroyed in Malaysia, not negotiate a trade deal ! Why does caring about persecuted minorities stop, when it is hindus that are on the recieving end ? hindu girls raped, abducted, forcibly converted in sindh, pak; hindu genocide in bangladesh 1971 (possibly million killed) ; ethnic cleansing in kashmir ( 0.5 million internally displaced ). why doesnt the congressi-communist heart bleed for persecuted hindus ?
Firebrand- Ha ha That was funny.
Prashant,
>> And of this CPIM….THEY OWN NEWSPAPER,TV CHANNEL,AMUSEMENT PARK ETC in Kerala???????
In Kerala, the CPM is still very much debating economic issues. I don’t know whats wrong with owning a Channel or news papers. Amusement park, obviously no. There is rampant corruption in Kerala CPM, but thats a different debate. Even in my above comment, I had only urged offstumped to encourage Karat brand of communism.
Yossarin,
Capitalism versus Communism is a global phenomenon. Fraternal bonds among world’s communists is not harmful. An India which doesn’t bother about Palestine, Sudan, Burma or Bangladesh is as dangerous as one which neglects rural poor, north east and the adivasis. Muslim anger against American policies, rural anger against large land-grabbing capitalists and the assault on free speech and suppression of minority opinion are all global issues.
When you criticize Ansari, you are right. Views of the Indian government cannot be whimsical. But criticizing left wing parties and intellects for doing what they should be doing (i.e. protesting imperialism) is just intolerance for left opinion.
“So there you have this Quixotic Alliance of Useful Idiots from India to the Americas ganging up to fight the Windmills of American Imperialism with Hamid Ansari playing Sancho Panza.”
Yossarin, very excellent simile. Extremely well put!!
Apparently Ansari thinks he’s Dick Cheney
without the mandate or power of position.
Balaji – man you are all over the map. You bet Iam intolerant of communism. It is immoral and evil. It has been anti-national in the past and is pretty close to being anti-national. This nation needs to be rid of the scourge of communism. Btw concern troubled hot spots has nothing to do with left wing or right wing. Private Individuals and entities with a compassionate moral compass can and shud do what is in their ability to provide humanitarian reliefs. Nations on the other hand must be guided purely by national interest. In a globalized world that “national interest” is more likely to be compassionate than selfish but the case has to be made purely on the baiss of why and how a sudan or palestine serve Indian National Interest.
Chandra – thanks, yeah if he thinks he is dick cheney we need to pack him off to an undisclosed location asap, out of sight out of mind.
Comrade Balaji,
>>An India which doesn’t bother about Palestine, Sudan, Burma or Bangladesh is as dangerous as one which neglects rural poor, north east and the adivasis.
Can you explain why Palestine should be of any greater concern to us than, say, Malaysia, where Indians recently protested racial discrimination?
Can an India that neglects ethnic cleansing on its own soil, and its own internally displaced people — Kashmiri Pandits readily come to mind — be a peaceful country? Don’t you think that might cause extreme reactions of the kind we have seen post-Godhra or Bombay 93?
>>Muslim anger against American policies,
Is America targetting “Muslims”? Do you seriously believe that? I thought it is generally Islamic fundamentalists who spread this kind of paranoia but alas even apparently sober people can twist their knickers into a knot over “American policies”.. Is Islam khatre mein hain, Comrade?
>>But criticizing left wing parties and intellects for doing what they should be doing (i.e. protesting imperialism)
Seriously, this is funny. Commies aren’t protesting any imperialism; they are sucking up to it. Chinese imperialism, that is. Look at their hatred for Dalai Lama, comrade. Do you know what these characters did when USSR invaded Afghanistan? They were all for subjugation of that country. Just where did you get this fancy notion that commies are against imperialism? Don’t you know how they sabotaged the freedom movement during WW2 to serve British interests? You sound brainwashed to me.
You mentioned commie “intellects”. I want to tell you about one of these intellects. A great intellect. He even went to JNU, the mecca of intellects. His name is Sitaram Yechury, nicknamed HateChury. He visited Romania towards the end of 1989. On his return to India, he published a glowing account of Ceausescu’s rule in Comrade Ram’s (another intellect!) The Hindu. Milk and honey were flowing in Romania. Socialism was achieved. Workers of Romania have untied, and dyslexics too. Romania was going from strength to strength under able communist leadership. It was a country of intellects.
Just a month after Ceuasescu had the pleasure of hosting Comrade Yechury, he (not Yechury) was hunted down Romanian countryside like a rabbit. Our intellect did not talk about this later development in The Hindu.
Yossarin,
you are just saying what I did. Governments can pursue national interest. But everyone in this country don’t have to think on the same lines. Bashing ‘communism’ has just become a hobby. Why should Indian commies be held responsible for all bad things done by Russia or China. If they take the good things from Bolsheviks, whats wrong with that? Besides I’m not calling on the nation to adopt left-of-center policies. Thats mostly disastrous. But I’m just saying, listening to the commies might help fine tune our national policy.
ot,
yep. Thanks for calling me ‘comrade’. Because people often brand me a Hindu fundamentalist! Kashmir Pandits – just as commies fight for some cause, right wingers should fight for the pundits. As simple as that. I’m not gonna answer your America vs Muslim point. Its blindingly obvious.
Freedom movement? Just as INC was fighting for independence, RSS was espousing Hindu revival, CPI were espousing communism and DMK was espousing backward class upliftment. So everyone who doesn’t vote for the Congress today is a traitor, is it?
Yechury/Ram/Karat brand of communism is far better than Surjeet/Basu/Biman brand of political opportunism.
Balaji,
//
But I’m just saying, listening to the commies might help fine tune our national policy.
//
Our national policy is fine enough with out the commies. For 50 years india paid the price for listening to the commies on every aspect of national to state to rural to jilla level policies. We all know what happened.
Now your Yechuries, Naxal rams, Carrots, are wanting to plunge indian national interest into oblivion just because an american friendship is against “muslim” interest.
//
Yechury/Ram/Karat brand of communism is far better than Surjeet/Basu/Biman brand of political opportunism.
//
Communism is anti-human and communists are anti-nationals PERIOD. Practicing it with different flavor does not make it any better.
Comrade Balaji,
>>Because people often brand me a Hindu fundamentalist
Which squared off nutjob called you a Hindu Fundamentalist!? Must be a CPIM worker, I bet.
>>Kashmir Pandits – just as commies fight for some cause, right wingers should fight for the pundits.
Two mistakes there, comrade.
One. Commies aren’t fighting for any “cause”. You have been severely deluding yourself that they are; and this is what I tried to set right. But you are persiting in your folly. Killing 80 million people was no “cause”, in case you are under the impression that it is. The three sinister ideologies of Communism, Nazism and Fascism fought for no “cause” other than establishing a totalitarian order; the civilized world has no use for them.
Second: it is not the job of “rightwingers” or “leftwingers” to fight for the pundits. It is the job first and foremost of the Indian government and the J&K government. It is then the job of every conscientious Indian. Beating our breasts about Palestine is not our priority.
>>I’m not gonna answer your America vs Muslim point. Its blindingly obvious.
Did you say you’re blind?
Let me repeat the question: Is America targetting “Muslims”? Islam khatre main hain kya, comrade?
>>Freedom movement? Just as INC was fighting for independence, RSS was espousing Hindu revival, CPI were espousing communism
and no doubt whilst Nazis were espousing Nazism just as communists were espousing communism ..
>>So everyone who doesn’t vote for the Congress today is a traitor, is it?
You sure are blind. Did you read what I wrote?
I said that the Indian commies are traitors because they sabotaged the Indian freedom movement to serve British commies’ interests.
>>Yechury/Ram/Karat brand of communism is far better than Surjeet/Basu/Biman
Tweedledum tweedledee..
Communists are traitors and should be packed off to Somalia or any western African country….